Consider achievements, peak performance, longevity and influence within the scope of this list. This is a curated starting field; candidates and eligibility are reviewed by Goatworthy editors.
One vote per player per candidate. Change or remove your vote at any time. Votes do not award quiz points.
A quarterback whose creativity, arm talent and postseason performances define his case.
A quarterback remembered for his quick release and prolific passing.
A quarterback whose passing and leadership helped shape the modern position.
A running back whose vision, durability and production defined his career.
A powerful running back known for speed, contact balance and explosive runs.
A linebacker whose instincts, tackling and leadership anchored elite defenses.
An interior defensive lineman known for quickness, leverage and relentless disruption.
A defensive back whose versatility and physical play helped define a championship defense.
Seven Super Bowl championships and a long record of postseason success.
A wide receiver whose production and longevity set the benchmark for the position.
A powerful running back who led the NFL in rushing in eight of his nine seasons.
A disruptive pass rusher who changed how offenses protected the quarterback.
Four Super Bowl championships and a reputation for precision under pressure.
Five regular-season MVP awards and an influential command of the offense.
An all-around running back known for endurance, versatility and physical running.
A running back celebrated for balance, elusive cuts and spectacular open-field runs.
A dominant defensive lineman whose strength and technique challenged generations of blockers.
A cornerback and return specialist known for coverage skills and game-changing speed.