Tom Brady
Seven Super Bowl championships and a long record of postseason success.
SIGN IN TO VOTE ↗0 up · 0 down
Photo: Barcex · via Wikimedia Commons · Source · CC BY-SA 4.0. Displayed in a cropped frame; source image linked for full view.
Voting criteria & how it works
Consider achievements, peak performance, longevity and influence within the scope of this list. This is a curated starting field; candidates and eligibility are reviewed by Goatworthy editors.
One vote per player per candidate. Change or remove your vote at any time. Votes do not award quiz points.
Joe Montana
Four Super Bowl championships and a reputation for precision under pressure.
SIGN IN TO VOTE ↗0 up · 0 down
Photo: photo taken by flcikr user Phil Hull · via Wikimedia Commons · Source · CC BY-SA 2.0. Displayed in a cropped frame; source image linked for full view.
Peyton Manning
Five regular-season MVP awards and an influential command of the offense.
SIGN IN TO VOTE ↗0 up · 0 down
Photo: All-Pro Reels · via Wikimedia Commons · Source · CC BY-SA 2.0. Displayed in a cropped frame; source image linked for full view.
Patrick Mahomes
A quarterback whose creativity, arm talent and postseason performances define his case.
SIGN IN TO VOTE ↗0 up · 0 down
Photo: All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA · via Wikimedia Commons · Source · CC BY-SA 2.0. Displayed in a cropped frame; source image linked for full view.
Dan Marino
A quarterback remembered for his quick release and prolific passing.
SIGN IN TO VOTE ↗0 up · 0 down
Photo: Webefex · via Wikimedia Commons · Source · CC BY-SA 2.0. Displayed in a cropped frame; source image linked for full view.
Johnny Unitas
A quarterback whose passing and leadership helped shape the modern position.
SIGN IN TO VOTE ↗0 up · 0 down
Photo: Kingkongphoto & www.celebrity-photos.com from Laurel Maryland, USA · via Wikimedia Commons · Source · CC BY-SA 2.0. Displayed in a cropped frame; source image linked for full view.